ct

Current cover

Comparatively Speaking: PPG vs. PEG

Contact Author Anthony J. O'Lenick, Jr.
Close
Fill out my online form.
ChemistLabMolecule850

PEG and PPG have been used in personal care for many years. These materials are also used in the biotechnology area, and in anti-foam compositions. The chemistry of PEG, PPG or combinations thereof in blocks or random chains have an impact on the functional properties of formulas. Knowledge of these materials will help the chemist understand both the effects of reacting these materials on fatty alcohols, and the performance of emulsifiers and wetting agents.

PEG Polymers

The term PEG (polyethylene glycol) refers to a class of polymers having the CAS number 25322-68-3 that are made by the reaction of ethylene oxide with ethylene glycol. This reaction is shown in Table 1.

Table 1. Synthesis of PEG Polymers

CTMayOLenick_Table1

Excerpt Only This is a shortened version or summary of the article you requested. To view the complete article, please log in or create an account. Registration is Free!

PEG polymers are sold by molecular weight, which in turn means by the n value, as specified above. Typical properties for PEGs are shown in Table 2.

Table 2. Typical Properties of PEG Polymers

CTMayOLenick_Table2

PEGs have great solubility in water, as they are soluble in all proportions at temperatures below the boiling point of water. This ability to interact with water is a major reason these polymers are used in formulation. PEG units are added to water-insoluble alcohols by the process of ethoxylation, providing a wide variety of surfactants (see Table 3).

Table 3. Synthesis of PEG Surfactants

CTMayOLenick_Table3

Non-Cosmetic Uses

PEG polymers can be made to meet the requirements of food additive regulations for indirect use as components intended to come into contact with food.PEG is also used as an inactive ingredient in the pharmaceutical industry, serving as a solvent, plasticizer, surfactant, ointment and suppository base, and as a tablet or capsule lubricant. PEG has low toxicity with systemic absorption of less than 0.5%.2 

PPG Polymers

The term PPG (polypropylene glycol) refers to a class of polymers having the CAS number 25322-69-4 and made by the reaction of propylene oxide with propylene glycol. This reaction is shown in Table 4Table 5 shows typical PPG properties.

Table 4. Synthesis of PPG Polymers 

CTMayOLenick_Table4

Table 5. Typical Properties of PPG Polymers

CTMayOLenick_Table5

PEG and PPG Differences

There are three salient functional differences between PEGs and PPGs. The first is water solubility, the second is liquidity and the third is the type of hydroxyl group present.

Regarding water solubility, PEG polymers are soluble in water over a wide range of molecular weights, whereas the solubility of PPG in water decreases rapidly with increasing molecular weight. In fact, at a molecular weight of 425, PPG is soluble in water but at a weight of 550, it is not.

The presence of the methyl group in PPGs precludes the formation of crystalline solids and keeps PPGs liquid at high molecular weights. On the other hand, PEG 600 has a melting point of 19°C.

Another difference, due to the methyl group, is the presence of secondary hydroxyl groups in PPG, which are less reactive than the primary hydroxyl groups in PEG. Lastly, it is well-known that PPG is less toxic than PEG, so biotechnology companies often replace PEGs with PPGs as solvents in pharmaceutical applications.3 A detailed summary of the safety assessment of alkyl PEG/PPG ethers as used in cosmetics is available from the Cosmetic Ingredient Review panel.

Poloxamers

A surfactant is a compound that contains two or more groups that have different solubilities; generally one part is water soluble and the other is oil soluble. Since PEG is water soluble and PPG is water insoluble, polymers that contain both of these groups will act as surfactants. This is, in fact, what we see in a class of compounds called poloxamers. The structure of two types of poloxamers are shown in Table 6.

Table 6. Poloxamer Structure

CTMayOLenick_Table6

Poloxamers are nonionic triblock copolymers composed of a central hydrophobic chain of polyoxypropylene (poly(propylene oxide)), PPO, flanked by two hydrophilic chains of polyoxyethylene (poly(ethylene oxide)), PEO. The word poloxamer was coined by the inventor, Irving Schmolka, who received the patent for these materials in 1973.4 It is interesting that this patent has been referenced in 165 subsequent patents as prior art.

Since the lengths of the polymer blocks can be customized, many different poloxamers exist that have slightly different properties. For the generic term poloxamer, these copolymers are commonly named with the letter P, for poloxamer, followed by three digits.

The first two digits multiplied by 100 give the approximate molecular mass of the polyoxypropylene core, and the last digit multiplied by 10 gives the percentage polyoxyethylene content. For example, P407 = a poloxamer with a polyoxypropylene molecular mass of 4,000 g/mol and 70% polyoxyethylene content.5

Alexander Tolstov explained the critical nature of the blocking of the polymers as follows. “The structural feature of PEG-PPG-PEG block copolymer is a sequential bonding to the corresponding polymer chains (poly(ethylene glycol) chain bonded with poly(propylene glycol) chain followed by bonding with another poly(ethylene glycol) chain). This results in characteristics of the block copolymer as an excellent surfactant (terminal polar PEG fragments and nonpolar PPG fragment in the center).

"... Another polymer, (poly(ethylene glycol-ran-propylene glycol)), is typical copolymer of ethylene oxide and propylene oxide with disordered structure. So the properties of such a copolymer could be expressed as averaged properties of PEG and PPG polymers without any characteristic features of the structural fragments along the copolymer chain.”7

Poloxamers have the water-insoluble PPG in the center and the water-soluble PEG groups on the outside. Here, a ranges from 2-130 and b ranges from 15-67, and the ratio of a:b determines the specific properties. Poloxamer uses are outline in Table 7.

Table 7. Poloxamer Uses6

CTMayOLenick_Table7

Reverse Poloxamers

Poloxamer polymers (see Table 8) are PEO/PPO linear block copolymers as well, with the configuration of: PEO-PPO-PEO. In contrast, reverse poloxamer polymers are PEO/PPO linear block copolymers but with a change in the configuration of the blocks: PPO-PEO-PPO. Here, since the hydrophobic blocks are now in the outer portion of the chains, their behavior in water is different.

Table 8. Reverse Poloxamers

CTMayOLenick_Table8

Water is a selective solvent for the ethylene oxide blocks in PEO/PPO copolymers. For the regular poloxamer configuration, spherical aggregates are easily formed since PPO blocks are placed inside the core, protected from the solvent by the outer PEO blocks.

In the reverse poloxamer (PPO-PEO-PPO), however, chains don’t easily form micelles. Rather, they form another type of aggregate such as flower-type micelles.

Silicone EO/PO Products

Finally, the realization that polypropylene oxide could be placed in a block manner into a silicone molecule emerges in U.S. Patent 8,153,106, which claims a silicone polymer. Its INCI name is PEG-9, PPG-9 dimethicone; this structure shown in Table 9. If the EO and PO were on the same Si group, the name would instead be PEG/PPG 9/9 dimethicone.

Table 9. PEG/PPG Block Polymer U.S. Patent 8,153,106

CTMayOLenick_Table9

The presence of the PEG and the PPG on two different Si groups with enough PPG to be water insoluble allows for the presence of a water insoluble hydrophobic group that is polar, due to the presence of ether and hydroxyl groups. This polar emulsifier allows for the wavelength at which the sunscreen agent avobenzone absorbs to shift. PPG polymers with a molecular weight above 500 provide water-insoluble polar materials that are very interesting in formulations.

References
All websites accesses June 1, 2018.

1. http://msdssearch.dow.com/PublishedLiteratureDOWCOM/dh_09ad/0901b803809ad5b0.pdf?filepath=polyglycols/pdfs/noreg/118-01797.pdf&fromPage=GetDoc
2. https://www.drugs.com/inactive/polyethylene-glycol-177.html
3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polypropylene_glycol
4. US Pat 3,740,421, Polyoxyethylene polyoxypropylene aqueous gels, assigned to I Schmolka and I Grosse (Jun 19, 1973)
5. https://www.slideshare.net/mayurpandya395/an-overview-peg-poloxamer
6. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poloxamer
7. https://www.researchgate.net/post/What_is_the_difference_between_PEG-PPG-PEG_block_copolymer_and_Polyethylene_glycol-ran-propylene_glycol
8. US Pat 8,153,106, Silicone based sun screening compositions with improved UVA1/UV ratios, assigned to D Lott and T O’Lenick (Apr 10, 2012)

Related Content

 

Close

Next image >