Dry, thin and sagging skin is among the most common complaints of women over the age of 50. This is due to reduced protective, preventative and regenerative aspects of aged skin. Aged skin is manifested by reduced stratum corneum (SC) moisturization, and although transepidermal water loss (TEWL) is known to be normal or improved with age, the epidermal barrier repair capacity after removing the superficial layers of the barrier by tape stripping is significantly impaired.1
Electron microscopy studies have shown a decreased size and number of keratohyalin granules (KHGs), the repository of profilaggrin in the keratinocytes, in aged skin. In this respect, reduced SC natural moisturizing factors (NMF) have been observed due to reduced amounts of profilaggrin-rich KHGs.2 Equally, abnormal intercellular lipid lamellae occur in aged skin, accompanied by a reduction in the levels of SC ceramides and especially ceramide EOS-linoleate.3 This is a result of the reduced lipid synthetic capacity of the epidermis that occurs during aging.
Further epidermal changes that occur with aging include the premature expression of involucrin4 and the decline in transglutaminase-1 and filaggrin levels.5 These changes can impact SC formation and maturation.
An age-related decline in the activity of the rate-limiting enzymes for ceramide, cholesterol and fatty acid synthesis has been reported; namely serine palmitoyltransferase, hydroxy-methyl-glutarycoenzyme-A reductase, and acetylcoenzyme-A carboxylase.6 All of these proteins participate in the production of a fully functional SC, but one family of proteins, the aquaporins, that forms channels to facilitate the transport of water across membranes has become of significant interest for its role in epidermal water maintenance.
Aquaporin-3 (AQP3) has been a particular focus because it is an aquaglyceroporin—i.e., it can co-transport glycerol, and its absence results in skin dryness, reduced SC hydration and elasticity, and delayed barrier recovery.7 Dumas et al.8 have reported an age-related decline in AQP3 expression that further manifests itself in photodamaged skin. Thus, a defective osmotic equilibrium could occur in the epidermis and account for the skin dryness observed in older subjects.
Brandner et al.9 also have discussed the importance of claudin-1 for the paracellular permeability of epidermal tight junctions.
Clearly, significant epidermal changes occur in aging skin that are responsible for its reduced protective, repair and regeneration capacity. The purpose of the presented work was to evaluate a lipid mixture containing the ceramides EOS, EOP, NP, NS and AP cholesterol (see Ceramide Key) and behenic acid, together with caprooyl-phytosphingosine and caprooyl-sphingosine.
The first group of lipids were chosen for known SC lipid lamellar-forming and skin protective characteristics10, whereas the latter were chosen for their effects as epidermal cell signalling molecules11,12 that aid epidermal repair and regeneration.
Materials and Methods
Human SC lipids were isolated, as previously described.13 An equimolar mixture of synthetic, nonanimal derived cholesterol, behenic acid and a unique combination of well-defined, synthetic, human skin-identical ceramides produced using biotechnology—namely sphingosine-derived CER EOS and CER NS, and phytosphingosine-containing CER EOP, CER NP and CER AP, was prepared. This lipid mixture was then used in small angle X-ray diffraction studies.
A combination of caprooyl-phytosphingosine and caprooyl-sphingosine was added to the described mixture and all lipids were finally preformulated in a multi-lamellar system designed to prevent crystallization to maximize efficacy. This blenda was then tested in clinical studies at a 5% use level.
In Vitro Small Angle X-ray Diffraction Studies
Measurements were taken at the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility (ESRF, Genoble) as described.13 Small angle X-ray diffraction (SAXD) provides information about the supramolecular organization of the barrier lipid molecules in multiple lamellae, consisting of a broad-narrow-broad sequence of electron lucent bands. The long periodicity phase (LPP) with a repeat distance of 12–13 nm is unique for the SC. It consists of two bilayers with a crystalline structure of 5–6 nm each called the short periodicity phase (SPP), separated by a narrow central lipid layer with fluid domains.15
Skin Bioengineering and Skin Biopsy Clinical Design
The described studies comply with the World Medical Association’s Declaration of Helsinki (2000) concerning biomedical research involving human subjects. The efficacy study was performed in vivo on 10 healthy volunteers with dry skin, five male and five females, in the age range of 35–65 years. All measurements were performed by the same investigator in an air-conditioned room (room temperature 18–22°C; air humidity ~30–50%). The materiala under evaluation was topically applied daily, 2 mg/cm2 of the skin surface, to both the volar forearm and buttock over a period of four weeks by a dermatologist; the contra-lateral areas were left untreated. Skin bioengineering parameters described below were measured on the volar forearm skin whereas at the end of the study, 4-mm punch biopsies were taken for the epidermal molecular analysis.
Determination of Molecular Markers by Real Time PCR
Total RNA was isolated and analyzed as described previously.13 Briefly, after reverse transcription with random hexamers, the PCR reactions were carried out on a monitorb using the SYBR
Green method. Each sample was analyzed in duplicate and 18S rRNA was used as internal standard. For comparison of relative expression in real time PCR control cells and treated cells, the 2 (-ΔΔ C(T)) method was used.14
Skin Bioengineering Tests
A paired Student´s t-test was performed to determine statistical differences between the data obtained from treated and untreated areas; the significance was set at the p < 0.05.
SAXD provides information on the periodicity of the SC lamellar lipid phase. The long periodicity phase of approximately 12 nm and the short periodicity phase at approximately 6 nm can be observed in both the natural human SC lipid mixture and the synthetic
The molecular ratios of the ceramides, nonanimal cholesterol and fatty acid were optimized in such a way that this mixture, even with the limited number of ceramides, closely resembles lamellar and lateral SC lipid organization, delivering the components necessary for formation of a skin-identical lipid barrier.
The effects of topical application of the product were assessed in an in vivo study covering both molecular and classical skin parameter readouts. mRNA for protein markers of epidermal differentiation—i.e., involucrin, transglutaminase-1, filaggrin and loricrin; rate-limiting steps of ceramide biosynthesis including serine palmitoyl transferase subunits 1 and 2, and ceramide glucose transferase-1; and epidermal water maintenance involving aquaporin-3 and claudin-1 were assessed on treated versus untreated buttock skin. All keratinocyte markers were found to be increased in the treated buttock versus the untreated control. These effects were specifically pronounced in the volunteer subgroup over the age of 50 (see Figure 2).
In the bioengineering study, skin barrier function (Figure 3a), skin hydration (Figure 3b) and skin elasticity (Figure 3c) were significantly improved after four weeks of topical treatment with the o/w cream containing the tested mixture.
The SAXD diffraction work described in this study has demonstrated that a mixture of CER EOS, EOP, NS, NP and AP, together with nonanimal-derived cholesterol and behenic acid, can mimic the lamellar ordering of human SC lipids known to be the most favorable conformation for skin protection. As the number of ceramides decline with aging, this lipid mixture could complement naturally occurring ceramides in skin. Non-natural ceramides have previously been shown to disrupt the lipid matrix.11
Many epidermal proteins are reduced or aberrantly expressed in skin aging. The lipid mixtures used in this study have been shown to increase mRNA for structural epidermal proteins, epidermal synthesis enzymes and proteins involved in epidermal water maintenance—i.e., filaggrin claudin-1 and AQP3. This is due to the cell signalling molecules used in the lipid mixture. These molecules have previously been shown to improve keratinocyte differentiation;12,13 however, this is the first study demonstrating not only improvements in gene-induction of these proteins in vivo but also the gene-induction of AQP3 in humans in vivo.
The results point out also that all markers observed were significantly upregulated, and in addition, a higher response for volunteers over age 50 was obtained for all of them.
Over the four-week study period, topical application of the lipid-containing o/w cream resulted in significant improvement of skin physiological parameters such as TEWL, SC hydration and skin elasticity. This is a result of the improvements in epidermal differentiation induced by the cell-signalling molecules and the skin barrier enhancing effects of the long chain ceramides varieties included, normally found in the SC.
This combination of lipids in a multi-lamellar system provides skin protection and improves preventative and regenerative aspects of mature skin, allowing formulators to produce products that target different aspects of the management of water in aged skin; i.e., rebuilding the SC barrier, increasing the presence of epidermal tight junction molecules, improving water flux into the keratinocytes through the aquaporin system and stimulating the synthesis of the NMF precursor protein profilaggrin.
1. JT Reed, PM Elias and R Ghadially. Integrity and permeability barrier function of photoaged human epidermis, Arch Dermatol 133(3) 395–6 (1997)
2. E Proksch, Dryness in chronologically and photoaged skin, ch 11 in Dry Skin and Moisturizers–Chemistry and Function, M Loden and HI Maibach, eds, CRC Press:Boca Raton, FL 117–126 (2006)
3. J Rogers et al, Stratum corneum lipids: The effect of aging and the seasons, Arch Dermatol Res 288(12) 765–70 (1996)
4. M Engelke et al, Effects of xerosis and aging on epidermal proliferation and differentiation, Br J Dermatol 137(2) 219–25 (1997).
5. Jl Contet-Audonneau, J Jeanmaire and G Pauly, A histological study of human wrinkle structure: Comparison between sun-exposed areas of the face with or without wrinkles and sun protected areas, Br J Dermatol 140(6) 1038–47 (1999)
6. R Ghadially et al, Decreased epidermal lipid synthesis accounts for altered barrier function in aged mice, J Invest Dermatol 106(5) 1064–9 (1996)
7. M Hara, T Ma and AS Verkman, Selectively reduced glycerol in skin of aquaporin-3 deficient mice may account for impaired skin hydration, elasticity and barrier recovery, J Biol Chem 277(48) 46616–21 (2002)
8. M Dumas et al, Hydrating skin by stimulating biosynthesis of aquaporins, J Drugs Dermatol 6 (6suppl) s20–24 (2007)
9. J Brandner et al, Tight junction proteins in the skin, Skin Pharmacol Physiol 19(2) 71–77 (2006)
10. U Wollenweber et al, Application of a skin identical lipid concentrate for enhanced skin moisturization and protection, SOFW 130(9) 2–7 (2004)
11. S Pillai et al, Synergy between vitamin D precursor 25-hydroxyvitamin D and short chain ceramides on keratinocyte proliferation and differentiation, J Investig Dermatol Symp Proc 1(1) 39–43 (1996)
12. P Lersch et al, Topical application of a sphingokine-lipid-mixture: Improvement of skin performance in humans addressed at a physiological and molecular level, IFSCC Congress (2006)
13. M de Jager et al, Acylceramide headgroup architecture affects lipid organization in synthetic ceramide mixtures, J Invest Dermatol 123(5) 911–916 (2004)
14. KJ Livak and TD Schmittgen, Analysis of relative gene expression data using real time quantitative PCR and the 2 (-ΔΔ C(T)) method, Methods 25 402–408 (2001)
15. JA Bouwstra, FER Dubbelaar, GS Gooris and M Ponec, The lipid organization in the skin barrier, Acta Derm Venereol suppl. 208 23–30 (2000)