Cosmetics & Toiletries

Application/Category Sponsored by

Email This Item!
Increase Text Size

Anticellulite Products: Ingredients and Efficacy Testing

Figures

  • Figure 1. Ingredient list for Cellulite Suppress Formula

    Figure 1. Ingredient list for Cellulite Suppress Formula

    Ingredients: Water (aqua), Isododecane, Ethylhexyl Palmitate, Pentylene Glycol, Butylene Glycol, Glycerin, Hydroxyethyl Acrylate/Sodium Acryloyldimethyl Taurate Copolymer, Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride, Gelidium Cartilagineum Extract (Rhodysterol, BiotechMarine), Laminaria Hyperborea Extract (Phycoboreane, BiotechMarine), Chenopodium Quinoa Seed Extract (Adipoless, Seppic), Sorbitan Laurate (and) Lauroyl Proline (Adiposlim, Seppic), Menthyl PCA, Centella Asiatica Extract, Aesculus Hippocastanum (Horse Chestnut) Seed Extract, Lecithin (vegetable), Menthol, Glycyrrhetinic Acid, Sodium Hyaluronate, Disodium EDTA, Phenoxyethanol, Caprylyl Glycol, Isoprene Glycol
    Cellulite Suppress Image

Tables

  • Table 1. Selected recent US Patents (P) and Patent applications (PA) for anticellulite ingredients

    Table 1. Selected recent US Patents (P) and Patent applications (PA) for anticellulite ingredients

    Company Year US Patent (P) or Patent Application (PA) Ingredient on which the patent is based
    Avon 2008

     P 7410658

    Alisma orientale
    Beiersdorf 2006 PA 20060002885  Bioquinones and isoflavones
    Bioderm Research  2004 PA 20040185069 Hydroxycitric acid derivatives
    Bioderm Research  2004  PA 20040146539 Nutraceutical composition
    Cognis  2004 PA 20040234480 Oligomeric proanthrocyanidens
    L'Oreal  2008  PA 20080242645 Xanthine base
    L'Oreal 2006 PA 20060134234 Xanthine base
    L'Oreal 2005  P 6878367 Sapogenin and xanthine
    Lab Expanscience 2006  PA 20060122246 Oxazoline
    Lipo 2007  P 7306809 Optically activated particles
     Lipo 2005 P 6946147 Optically activated particles
    Lipo 2004 P 6808722 Optically activated particles
    Lipo 2004 PA 0052742 Optically activated particles
    Lipo 2003 P 6613359 Optically activated particles
    Lipo 2003 P 6586013 Optically activated particles
    Lipo 2003  PA 20030170189 Optically activated particles
    Lipo 2003 PA 20030152537 Optically activated particles
    Lipo 2003 PA 20030147821 Optically activated particles
    Lipo  2003 PA 20030104022 Optically activated particles
     Lipo 2002 PA 20020192260 Optically activated particles
    Lipo 2002 PA 20020192248 Optically activated particles
    Parfums Christian Dior 2002 P 6447782 Skeletonema algae
    Pentapharm 2005 P 6953583 Conjugated linoleic acid
    Pierre Fabre  2007  P 7192613 Allium sativum bulb absolutes
    Pierre Fabre 2005 P 6852343 Garlic bulb extracts
     Pierre Fabre 2004 PA 20040258777 Allium sativum bulb absolutes
    Sederma  2007 PA 20070043109 Diterpene
    Seppic 2008 PA 20080200534 Lauryl proline, ester of anhydrohexitol and of aliphatic carboxylic acid
    Vincience 2008 PA 20080227725 Peptides
    Vincience 2006 PA 20060013794 Peptides with sequences Arg-Gly-Ser

By: Bud Brewster, Cosmetics & Toiletries magazine
Posted: December 23, 2008, from the January 2009 issue of Cosmetics & Toiletries.

In August of last year, the Wall Street Journal Health Blog reported that there was "not much high-quality evidence" for the effectiveness of cellulite treatments;1 for example, massage treatments produce swelling that reduces dimpling, but the dimpling reduction is only temporary. In addition, lasers or energy sources that are claimed to affect the fat cells under the skin have not been proven to have any long-term effect, according to the report. "There's nothing that has been shown in any objective way to create improvement for cellulite," Robert A. Weiss, then president-elect of the American Society for Dermatologic Surgery, told the Wall Street Journal.

What was he thinking? Where was the discussion of the huge range2 of anticellulite products and professional methods available to treat cellulite--from topical products and oral regimens, to garments? How could he ignore the body of technical knowledge generated by the suppliers of anticellulite ingredients, and the manufacturers of anticellulite products?

Nevertheless, Weiss gets some support from Enzo Berardesca at the San Gallicano Dermatological Institute in Rome. In 2006, Berardesca admitted that the efficacy of cellulite treatments is often debated. He wrote, "The evaluation of cellulite is based principally on clinical observation, thigh circumference measurements, body mass index and thermography, but for testing anticellulite products, more objective and noninvasive methods of evaluation are requested."2

Both Weiss and Berardesca are asking for objective proof that anticellulite products work. This "Bench & Beyond" column examines selected patents, journal articles, product promotion pieces and one dissertation--all from the last six years--for signs indicating that objective proof is on the way.

Cellulite